Putting together a carnival can take anywhere from about five minutes to many, many hours.

The five minute version takes advantage of the “InstaCarnival” feature on BlogCarnival.com. The InstaCarnival is a post that has a number of lines with the format:

Blogger presents blog post, posted at blog, saying “comment”

for each post submitted through the BlogCarnival.com interface.  This is a perfectly valid way to put a carnival together.  It’s straightforward.  It’s clear.  It’s also pretty cookie-cutter.  (This isn’t a slam on BlogCarnival — if computers start writing as well as, or better than, humans, we’re in trouble as bloggers!)

I’ve started with the InstaCarnival template with a few carnivals I’ve hosted.  I massage the text a little bit, but it sure is helpful if you’re away from your high-speed internet connection and you have a carnival to put together.

The many, many hours version involves not only reading the submitted posts (!) but also putting together a kind of show.  These are labors of love for the hosts.  Sometimes you get the carnival in verse, with an old video game flair, with a podcast, with celebrities, or even with a Renaissance faire!

(These are just a few examples!  If you have a great one to add to the list, post a comment!)

Now the big question:  Which kind is better?

The InstaCarnival type (a list of posts and not much else) is clear but unimaginative on the part of the host.  It saves the host time.  For a big carnival, the return on investment for the host is pretty good: lots of traffic and lots of trackbacks without much work.

The SuperCarnival type (like the ones linked to above) are really cool to look at and will probably get more link love (links in posts) and more buzz than the InstaCarnival.

If it were just backlinks and buzz, the well-put-together carnival would be a hands-down winner.  But I don’t think it’s that simple.  For all of the flash of these carnivals, how much time did you spend clicking through to the posts?  Was dressing up the carnival a service or a disservice to the people who submitted to the carnival?  Sure, the good-looking carnival gets more traffic, but does it get more click-throughs?  And if hosts did this week after week, calling more attention to the carnival than to the posts, would the submitters keep submitting?

I don’t really know.  But I do think that the “dull” carnivals put the spotlight on the posts more than the “exciting” ones.  It’s easier to find what posts you want to read in the simple carnival than in the ornate one.

So I wouldn’t feel slighted with a drab carnival if the little chunk with my post was easy to understand and encouraged readers to click through to my article.  On the other hand, I also wouldn’t feel slighted if a really crazy cool carnival drew a bunch of traffic and gained a wider audience, a few of which clicked through to my blog for the first time.

What’s your opinion?

• Screen the submissions with clear rules If there are no rules for what can be submitted to your blog carnival, then just about anything will be submitted!  The overall quality of posts submitted to the Carnival of Debt Reduction had been going downhill a touch.  Lots of automatic carnival submission was happening through BlogCarnival.com, and I......
• Carnivalize yourself once in a while Blog carnivals are meant to be a collection of posts from other blogs on a specific topic, but what about a Carnival of You?  What about putting together a bunch of your favorite links from your own blog, and slapping a Carnival moniker on it? Why not? Clever Dude has......
• Easy themes your blog carnival Adding a theme to your carnival doesn't have to be difficult.  It can be as easy as looking around you and searching Wikipedia. Interspersing a few interesting facts about a timely topic, regardless of whether that topic is closely tied to the particular blog carnival, dresses it up substantially.  It's......
• How tightly does one need to control a carnival? As blog carnivals get big and well-established, the traffic gets pretty substantial.  This attracts more posts, both good and bad.  The good posts, because it's a good, long-standing carnival that bloggers want to submit to.  The bad posts, because it's an easy, high-traffic link for not that much work.Initially, when......

• Earn Some Extra Green This Spring with a Garage Sale When you think of spring, what comes to your mind? Some people might think of spring flowers and warm weather. Others might think of rain showers and thunderstorms. For some bargain hunters, however, spring is the beginning of garage sale season. Garage sales serve to benefit shoppers and sellers alike.......
• Daily Rec: A Backdrop of 80's Polysynths and Extreme 8-bit Tunes! Set against a backdrop of 80's polysynths the extreme 8-bit tune dot's in and out creating a lovely mellow blend. There are several versions of this song, but I've found the instrumental is my favourite, simply because the music is so relaxed and perfect....
• First Ever Youth Olympic Games The International Olympic Committee has given their approval on the sports program for the first ever Summer Youth Olympic Games. The Youth Olympic Games will be held 2010 in Singapore. Overall, there will be over 3500 athletes competing in 201 events, divided by age groups 15 to 16, 16 to......
• Did Powerball tickets beat the S&P last year? This morning in Sunday school someone threw out that a substantial fraction of Americans have a lottery win comprising their retirement plans.  ("How did we get to talking about gambling in Sunday school?" you might ask.  It was just a chance discussion, that's all.) I just shook my head at......